Comprehensive Comparison: KeyCare Plus vs Essential Smart Saver
| Member | KeyCare Plus (Band: R17,251+) | Essential Smart Saver | Difference |
|---|
Medical schemes base their payout on the Discovery Health Rate (DHR). However, independent private specialists frequently charge 300% to 400% of this rate.
• A family Gap Cover policy costs roughly R350 – R480 per month.
• It covers that R16,000 shortfall up to 500% of tariff, as well as hospital co-payments for scopes and casualty admissions.
• The Math: By switching to Essential Smart Saver, you save R3,553/month. Even after buying Gap Cover for R400/month, you still keep over R3,100 in cash every single month with superior private protection.
| Benefit Area | KeyCare Plus | Essential Smart Saver | Family Recommendation |
|---|---|---|---|
| In-Person GP Consultations | Unlimited (R0 co-pay), strictly 1 nominated GP | Unlimited (R135 co-pay), any Smart Network GP | Smart Saver (Choice) |
| Virtual Consultations | 1 Urgent session per person | Unlimited via Discovery app (R0 co-pay) | Smart Saver |
| Hospital Network | Restricted KeyCare network | Smart Hospital Network (Netcare/Mediclinic) | Smart Saver (Top Tier) |
| Kids Casualty Emergency | Not covered out of hospital | 1 casualty visit/child (R135 co-pay) for injuries | Smart Saver |
| Paediatric Sports Injury | None | X-rays, 2 specialists, 4 physio visits | Smart Saver |
See how much money stays in your bank account after paying the R135 GP co-payments:
* Even if your family visits the GP 50 times in a year, you still keep over R35,000 in cash compared to KeyCare Plus.